• OverThePylon

    OTP covers Ball State University football from the blog perspective in the most overzealous manner possible, proving that as long as there is someone with enough free time you can obsess over anything.
  • Connect to OTP

  • OTPcast on Itunes

  • OTP Messageboard

  • OTP’s Archive

  • Sort OTP

  • Pick out all the best college football tickets, including great seats for Ball State games, at Vivid Seats. Their site is the favorite place to find ordering information for all discount sports tickets. Hot passes this season include Boise State football tickets and Razorback football tickets.
    Looking for Sports Gifts? Find everyday wholesale prices on the hottest College Fan Gear and Team Apparel. Or if you want something signed by your favorite players, check Autograph-Sports.com out for a wide selection of Authentic Football Sports Memorabilia and Autographed Cards.

Joshua Howard Shares his All-Star Experience

Ball State safety Joshua Howard had a fun week in sunny Southern California while the rest of us were sliding on the ice in Muncie.

Howard shared his experience at Saturday’s NFLPA Collegiate Bowl with OTP.

Joshua Howard, coming to an NFL team near you.

“This is one of the best football experiences in my life. It’s probably not better than my freshmen year after we finished the season 12-0 or the atmosphere at Lucas Oil Stadium for the Indiana game. But this moment is up there. I have been fortunate enough to meet and be coached by Dick Vermeil, Priest Holmes, Isaac Bruce, Ray Crockett and many more. We had a live personal comedy show by Mike Epps and I got my hair cut by Kobe Bryant’s personal barber (so I’ve been told). This is a wonderful experience for me as a player and a man. These NFL legends are teaching us how to be better football players on the field and better men off the field. The NFLPA Bowl has impressed me every day I have been here (it being in California doesn’t hurt either). I will be playing for the National team (black jersey) and I will be wearing number 32. Also, I will be starting! Again, I will do my best to represent everyone involved with Ball State football from the players, coaches and other staff to the students and citizens of Muncie, Indiana. I would not be where I am without those guys and especially to my family and hometown, Inkster, MI. I will be representing you as well with all my power. As always God bless and GO CARDS!”

This is what Howard shared after the game on his individual performance.

“I had 7-8 tackles and one big hit! I started the game. Then I came back in with four minutes left in the 2nd. Then I came in half way thru the 3rd and played for the rest of the game.”

Howard was the starting safety for the National team’s 20-14 victory. I was unable to watch the game as it was on the new NBC Sports Network which is nowhere to be found on basic cable.

But this game could have been played on the Lifetime channel and still would have provided great exposure for Howard. The amount of playing time a coaching icon in Vermeil gave him has to be a great sign. Making as many tackles as he did does not hurt either.

The names Howard met feature major star power. Playing on the field was clearly a small portion of his total experience.

At least, Howard and fellow safety Sean Baker, who also participated in an All-Star game, will make draft day and training camp very interesting for Ball State fans. Here is to hoping whether as a draft pick or undrafted free agent, they will both be given a strong opportunity to make an NFL roster.  Best of luck Cardinals!

Athletic Director Tom Collins to Leave Ball State in June

Fare thee well, Tom


You can go ahead and disregard those last few statements I’ve made where I said there wouldn’t be any sort of news coming out of Muncie of a sizable nature considering its the offseason. Bombshell alert per BSU press release…

Athletic director Tom Collins announced today that he plans to leave Ball State at the end of his current contract, which ends on June 30, 2012.

“I’ve truly enjoyed working with our coaches, staff and student-athletes over the past six years,” said Collins. “As a team, we’ve accomplished a great deal while overcoming some challenges. I’m proud of what we’ve been able to achieve.

“I’m looking forward to returning to the Southwest, where my wife, Kathy, and I can be closer to our children. There are opportunities there that I want to explore, and I think this is the right time to do so.”

President Jo Ann Gora thanked Collins for his service to Ball State and his willingness to assist in the transition to a new athletic director. “Tom has been committed to Ball State athletics since his arrival,” said Gora. “I appreciate his hard work and service to the university. In his time here, we have had significant competitive successes, from back-to-back bowl appearances to NCAA appearances by softball, women’s volleyball, and of course women’s basketball’s dramatic victory over Tennessee in 2009. This fall, we packed Lucas Oil Stadium to see our football team beat IU for the second consecutive time.

“Tom has had a positive impact throughout our athletics program. He was highly involved in the completion of the Scheumann Stadium project, including the successful sale of all the new suites and club level seats. His fundraising efforts led to the creation of the Briner Sports Complex, which includes dramatic new facilities for several of our women’s teams. On a national scale, Ball State has been recognized for its gender equity plans, and Tom has served on both the MAC finance subcommittee and the NCAA Division I Amateurism Cabinet.
“I am particularly pleased with Tom’s commitment to maintaining an equal emphasis on both academic success and athletic success when setting expectations for our coaches and student-athletes.”

Gora plans to form a search committee and begin a national search immediately, anticipating that the position will be posted soon. “Given the strength of the department currently, I believe this will be a very attractive opportunity. Tom has bolstered our compliance efforts and staff. We have a very strong complement of coaches on board. I’m confident we will attract a competitive pool of candidates.”

Soooo… that happened. This blog has had an interesting relationship with Tom Collins, and while there are things I can say without question he hasn’t handled fantastically well, he did hire Billy Taylor and Pete Lembo. Granted, he also hired Stan Parrish, so there’s that. More on this as it comes, but we do wish Collins well as he transitions out of Muncie. Looks like President Gora has quite the task in front of her… hiring an AD that the fans won’t be ready to drag through the streets the minute something goes wrong.

Ball State Safeties Play in All-Star Games

I need no thumb to feast on souls

The “Safety U” nickname I gave Ball State in my previous post is gaining more and more steam.

Ball State safeties Sean Baker and Joshua Howard have or will soon participate in a college all-star game.

Baker played Monday in the Casino Del Sol All-Star Game in Arizona. According to Doug Zaleski of the Muncie Start Press he recorded a tackle as a backup.

Baker was also healthy for the game which is a good sign for his draft status. Ball State fans are used to seeing a cast on No. 25 so his performance Monday should put to rest some of those health concerns among NFL scouts.

Howard will play in the NFLPA Collegiate Bowl out in California this Saturday. According to the game’s website the all-star team Howard is on will be coached by NFL great Dick Vermeil.

After Saturday’s game Howard can say he has been coached by Brady Hoke, and Dick Vermeil. Not many can say that. Although many are probably glad they were not coached by Stan Parrish for two years so you take the good with the bad I suppose.

I have not made contact with Howard yet but if he shares any moments from his all-star experience I will post them here at OTP. Go “Safety U” go.

2011 Season Highlight Video Released

If you weren’t lucky enough to be in attendance at the end of year banquet for BSU football, you probably haven’t seen the official highlight video released for the 2011 season. It was always a bit of a burr in my saddle that this sort of thing never saw the light of day at Ball State like at some other programs, but kudos to Coach Lembo and the football staff who seem to “get it”. To borrow a line from Boiler Room, sometimes you have to “act as if”. No giant stadium? No huge fan network? No real fervor or passion beyond the loyal but small following of the Cardinals? Pay that no mind. Act as if there are large groups clamoring for ways to feel connected and energized about Ball State football. In other words, fake it till you make it. And this is a great first step. Enjoy!

Ball State Announces Roster Additions, Sources Confirm Subtractions

New addition and New Edition are not the same thing

As we reference most every offseason, the news coming out of the Cardinals’ nest after the last game of the year slows to a snail’s pace. One of the unfortunate things of covering a smaller market team is that there is not the rabid following like the Alabamas and LSUs of the world to fawn over each and every little trickle of information. At those schools, someone’s twitter posting can set the fanbase in a tizzy, whereas in Cardinal land, it’s usually a player leaving, a player getting added, or a major rules violation that moves the needle at all in the long cold winter known as the offseason. Today, there’s a lot of column A, a little of column B, and thankfully none of column C. Yet.

Coach Lembo has certainly made use of the post-season transfers, as we saw this past season with the stable of running backs that seemingly came out of nowhere to carry the load left by the void of Eric Williams and Cory Sykes. So when it comes to roster additions outside the normal scope of recruiting and such, I certainly trust the talent evaluations being done in Muncie these days. The 2011 season is just a week or so in the books, but we already have our first bit of news about new faces for next fall. From the BSU release…

Pete Lembo has announced the addition of three mid-year signees plus the return of one student-athlete for the 2012 roster.

Joining the program at mid-year are Selwyn Frazier (Independence Community College), Oga Igbinosun (Rahway High School) and Chris Pauling (T.W. Andrews High School), while Matthew Mosley returns to the Cardinals after sitting out the 2011 season to concentrate on academics.

“We are pleased to welcome these new student-athletes to the university for the spring semester, while also glad to have Matthew Mosley return to the program,” Lembo says. “Selwyn, Oga and Chris are quality young men who are excited to be at Ball State. They have a great opportunity to acclimate themselves academically, athletically and socially this spring. They will also help to create greater internal competition on our defense at positions where we need to improve. Matthew is a quality young man who loves Ball State and is passionate about the game of football. He did a nice job staying connected during his hiatus from the program. We are hopeful he returns as a more focused and mature student.”

Frazier earned two letters while playing for Independence Community College in 2010 and 2011. A graduate of Wichita East High School in Wichita, Kansas, Frazier is expected to play safety for the Cardinals. As a team captain in his second year at ICC, Frazier ranked second on the team with 63 tackles. He earned All-Jayhawk Conference honors in his second season, while helping the team to its first ever playoff appearance in his first campaign. At Wichita East, Frazier was a team captain as a senior and earned all-conference honors in his final season. He helped Wichita East to a 5-5 mark in his senior season and earned four letters for Coach Brian Byers.

Igbinosun earned three letters at Rahway High School in New Jersey for Coach Gary Mobley. He helped his team to a 6-5 mark as a senior and a 24-10 record in his career. Igbinosun, who graduated from Rahway in December, is expected to play defensive end for the Cardinals. At Rahway, Igbinosun managed 98 tackles, 16 tackles for loss and 12 sacks as a senior. He set a school record with six tackles for loss, including four sacks as a senior. Igbinosun managed 18 career sacks. He was selected to the New Jersey North-South All-Star Game and was named the New Jersey Game Most Valuable Player. A second-team all-state selection as a senior, Igbinosun earned all-area first team honors and was a Super 100 New Jersey selection in his final season. In addition, he was named the Mid-State 39 Defensive Player of the Year in his final season. Igbinosun, the son of Solomon and Mercy Igbinosun, also competed in wrestling, track and basketball at Rahway.

Pauling, a December graduate of T.W. Andrews High School in North Carolina, has joined the Cardinals and is expected to play safety at Ball State. Pauling earned three letters for Coach Rodney McKoy at Andrews and heoped the Red Raiders to an 8-3 mark as a senior and a 32-12 record in his career. Pauling managed 86 tackles, two forced fumbles and one blocked punt, which he returned for a touchdown in his senior season. He totalled 260 tackles, eight forced fumbles, three blocked punts, 20 sacks and two interceptions in his career. Pauling was an All-PAC 6 Conference selection as a junior and senior. He was named all-area and selected to play in the South Carolina/North Carolina Shrine Bowl as a senior. The son of Chris and Rosalyn Pauling, he managed a 3.1 grade-point average in high school and was a three-time selection to the Academic All-PAC 6 Conference team.

Mosley played in all 12 games as a true freshman during the 2010 season and earned his first letter. He recorded his first career tackle vs. Southeast Missouri State and tallied a career high two tackles in six games. A graduate of Morgan Park High School in Chicago, Ill., Mosley played outside linebacker for the Cardinals.

These sorts of additions are absolutely critical for several reasons, first and foremost because of the added depth it provides to some very critical positions for the Cardinals. Two safetys and a DE to go along with the returning LB Matthew Mosley means that one of the areas of consternation for 2011 and outright concern for 2012 has at bare minimum more warm bodies to fill in for the nicks and scratches that arise over the course of a season. As we saw on the field, heard in the coach’s comments, and read in the various program communications, there is perhaps no more critical an area of improvement for the Cards than depth. I would say it’s safe to say it’s not where Coach Lembo would prefer it to be, but it’s better than last year and seemingly getting better by the day. Perhaps the thing that will be overlooked but in my opinion is quite impressive is the geographic location of the new additions. Kansas, New Jersey, and North Carolina all get added to the roster footprint, and in case you haven’t been paying attention, BSU has never had a real national base from which to recruit. Each and every state that gets added to the roster gives a better recruiting advantage for players from that particular region and ideally means the Cardinals can branch out a bit from their pre-established stomping grounds of Indiana, Ohio, and the general rust belt area.

It isn’t all sunshine and roses, though, as mentioned above, that pesky column B means there’s some subtraction to go along with the additions. Multiple independent sources have confirmed to OTP that sophomore Aaron Morris did not return to Ball State for the spring semester because of academic issues. Whether that is a permanent outcome or a short-term time away to correct some areas of need a la Matthew Mosley is unclear, but OTP wishes Aaron all the best as he gets his academic house in order. Morris was a stalwart in the linebacking crew who had a bright future, a nose for the ball, and an ability to make the critical tackle but without the “student” piece of the student-athlete, the “athlete” portion becomes moot. Here’s hoping that this is more roadblock than derailment and we see Aaron back in Cardinal and White soon.

Go Cards!

EXCLUSIVE: Ball State Safety Joshua Howard Prepares for NFL Draft

Writers note: Sometimes as a reporter, columnist, blogger or rascal, you catch a break. I am friends with Ball State safety Joshua Howard and he was able to inform me on his future plans this week. At a newspaper this would be a conflict of interest but at a blog it is fair game.  As Charlie Sheen would say if he were a Ball State fan, “Wenning!”

Joshua Howard

Ball State Safety Joshua Howard is trying to take his talents to the NFL. It is good to see Ball State players place themselves in a position to play on Sundays. Howard is away from Muncie preparing for the draft and I can speak for everyone here at OTP we wish him the best. Here is a statement from No. 20 himself he gave me over Facebook.

“I am currently in Richmond, Virginia training for Ball State’s NFL pro-day. I just got in on Tuesday (1-10-12), and I will be back in Muncie around the end of February/beginning of March. I have a full out workout schedule that starts at 5 a.m. and ends at 7 p.m. (of course with meals and breaks in between all of that). I was contacted by a trainer, and I let my agent know immediately about this wonderful opportunity. I am also still a Ball State student, I am enrolled in online classes. So I will be able to still graduate and train for NFL preparation. It’s a wonderful situation I am in, and I am extremely thankful for everyone who made this possible. So, I will be back around Spring Break but until then, good luck to the entire Football program with preparation for next season. Also, thank you to everyone who has a part in every bit of my success, I greatly appreciate it. Until I return, as always — GO CARDS!”

It is nice to see that Howard is going to still be able to graduate while preparing for the draft. I guess that saying “you can’t have your cake and eat it too” was false. It is also impressive Howard all ready has an agent. The only agent most Ball State students could get is if we robbed a bank and were assigned a crummy public defender. Not that we would actually do that.

The Cardinals need more alumni in the NFL. Each touchdown pass Drew Brees throws in New Orleans is free marketing for Purdue. Ball State can only point to a couple of punters as their NFL products right now. If Howard and fellow safety Sean Baker (a lock to be drafted in the first four rounds) can have successful NFL careers than maybe Ball State can ditch nickname “Punter U” for the new moniker of “Safety U.” Granted, that name may confuse Ball State with a Lifeguard class.

Even more important is what this says about the senior class. Howard, Baker, and maybe center Kreg Hunter will get a chance to prove themselves in NFL training camps this summer. This senior class has gone through multiple coaches, coordinators, and experienced more drama than most recruiting classes should ever have to face. From the penthouse in 2008 (12-2) to the outhouse in 2009 (2-10) to a middle-class home in the suburbs in 2011 (6-6). Is this college football or is this real estate?

Coach Pete Lembo has been given a bulk of the credit for turning the ship around but the senior leadership on the roster was a huge help. They knew what it was like to win and made sure their younger teammates were just as passionate about returning to glory.

For now we wish Howard the best. I could list the NFL teams that are in need of a safety but that would double the size of this column. “Safety U” is sounding better and better all ready.

Catching a football with No. 20 closing in can ruin your weekend as this Central Michigan player is about to learn the hard way.

2011 Ball State Season Rewind: Cards Go to the Movies Part 2

For those who missed part 1 in the season rewind you can find it here.

Party in Muncie! Your Cardinals won 6 games in 2011.

Super 8: Ball State 23 Ohio 20

Just when everyone had Ball State out your Cardinals went on the road and beat a division champion. I was away from technology that weekend and asked a friend to check the score on his phone. When it said Ball State won 23-20 I thought it was a mistake.

It was true. The defense won the game forcing three turnovers. Safety Joshua Howard had a pick and fumble recovery and good for him. He had been in Sean Baker’s shadow for three seasons so it was great to see him able to run the show when No. 25 was injured. Both safeties should be on NFL rosters this fall.

Super 8 is a great movie but I cannot name a single actor in the film. That’s similar to Ohio game. The game was collective effort of small and medium-sized plays that added up to a big victory.

The Adjustment Bureau: Ball State 31 Central Michigan 27

Ball State came out flat in this game and trailed 17-3 at the half. The few fans who were there thought it was Temple all over again and the Ohio win must have been a fluke. This game probably displayed Pete Lembo’s coaching ability best as his halftime adjustments worked perfectly. Ball State scored 21 points in the third and held on for the win.

The fact that Ball State is inconsistent is not a big concern right now. Keith Wenning is still learning the quarterback position as he did not play it much in high school. If the second half team shows up more in 2012 and 2013 we may be looking at MAC championship in Muncie. Maybe an undefeated season, top 15 ranking and a bowl game against Tulsa in Alabama. What? Too soon?

Cowboys and Aliens: Western Michigan 45 Ball State 35

Lembo showed coaching brilliance against Central Michigan but Western was probably his most questionable game. Ball State went for it on fourth down four times and only converted once. The three failures occurred in field goal range and swung momentum to the Broncos each time. I like the gun-slinger mentality Lembo brings to the table but you can win every gun fight. There is a fine line between aggressiveness and recklessness and the Cardinals probably crossed it in Kalamazoo.

On a side note I watched this game online and was amazed at how the Bronco commentators complained about the low attendance of about 16,000 fans. At Ball State, 16,000 fans is huge a crowd. At Western Michigan it is a slow week. Just another example of how much the program needs to grow.

The Help: Ball State 33 Eastern Michigan 31

Thank God for Eastern Michigan. The Eagles had more yards, more first downs, double the time of possession, won the turnover battle but still found a way to lose. Ball State played well enough to win but Eastern Michigan gave this game away with 12 penalties and poor play calling in the red zone. Thanks for the help Eastern! Then again Ball State gave away the 2010 meeting in Muncie so I guess we are even now.

The defensive highlight of the year occurred in the last two minutes of this game as Ball State forced Eastern to kick a field goal after having first and goal inside the one. If the Eagles punch it in the Cardinals probably would not have won and ended up an unsatisfying 5-7. Statistically, Ball State had one of the weakest defenses in the MAC but stats fail to take into account coming up big in key moments like this one.

Green Lantern: Northern Illinois 41 Ball State 38

We found out that Ball State is the Ryan Reynolds in the MAC in this game. Good enough to get roles but not good enough to be the first banana of successful blockbuster (Green Lantern certainly was not).

Sure, officiating was questionable, but Ball State had their shot to slay the alpha dog of the conference on the road. The offense stalled in the fourth quarter and the defense could not get stops. The game was primetime on ESPNU on a night where the NBA was still dealing with lawyers. The Cardinals had a chance to grab the lead role but they are not there yet.

In the future Ball State will be the star of the MAC like it was in 2008. The fact the Cardinals had a chance to claim glory in Lembo’s first season is a credit to his staff and players, but it is hard to jump from 4-8 to the MAC Championship game in one year. Ball State was good enough to be respectable in the 2011 season and Cardinals fans could not say that a year ago.

Green Hornet: Toledo 45 Ball State 28

I thought Green Hornet was going to be a good movie much like I thought Toledo would be a good game. Then I saw Seth Rogan in the lead role and I just knew it was a waste of time. I had the same reaction watching Toledo’s stud wide receiver Eric Page zigzag through the Ball State secondary. The game could not end fast enough.

I kept thinking “If Ball State keeps it close then maybe they get a bowl invite at 6-6.” With each Toledo score the odds became smaller and smaller to eventually none. Watching the fourth quarter online (I think I know one student who actually went) felt more like a funeral. The 2011 season was over.

Note to the MAC, NO MORE BLACK FRIDAY GAMES!

The Hangover Part 2: Bowl season

Another year without a bowl game for Ball State. I am proud of what Ball State accomplished. The wins over IU and Army were satisfying enough for me even if Ball State lost the rest of their games. There are reasons to be optimistic as well as reasons to be concerned next season. Just like every other team.

Think of it this way. It is currently better to be a Ball State football fan than a Penn State and Indiana football fan. Never thought I would be able to say that year ago. Not bad as we go into the thick of basketball season.

MAC Officially Unveils the Newer, Shinier, Balanced-er Divisions and BSU Opponents

I know that like me, many of you sat and watched BCS game after BCS game go down to the wire and fill you with not only excitement, passion, and love of football but an overwhelming curiosity about how the MAC and its higher ups were spending this holiday season. While I would have been more than content to believe the MAC leaders were somewhere on the streets of New Orleans last night vomiting up happy hour hurricanes before attempting the “I knew Brady back when he was flipping over golf carts at Muncie scrambles” pick up strategy to some comely coeds still high on Hoke-a-mania. Or better yet, perhaps they were watching the Oklahoma State-Stanford game with a smug indignation about how much better MAC kickers appear to be than just about anyone else on significantly larger stages, given the referees don’t actually screw you out of an extra point and effectively giftwrap a loss before kicking you in the balls. Or perhaps they were lazily soaking in rays in Pasadena for the Rose Bowl Game-Presented By Vizio since title sponsorship like the AllState Sugar Bowl or Discover Orange Bowl is for low class douchers, not the Granddaddy Of Them All. Apparently, though, the MAC muckety mucks were hard at work in their MidAmerican bunker busily getting the i’s dotted and t’s crossed for the coming season with UMass. Welcome to Finally Balanced-ville… population MidAmerican Conference.

After enduring the last decade or so with an imbalance of league teams and 13 total members, the MAC finally got itself even with UMass joining as a football only member in the MAC East. That left the split at 8-6, so Bowling Green is heading to the West where they will join Ball State as division members and will appear on the Cards’ schedule yearly now. That also means that the Cards will now only have two crossover games for MAC East opponents, and unfortunately, we don’t get to ride the sucktrain of UMass. Ohio at home and on the road to Miami are our East opponents for 2012, and the other unfortunate bit of news is BG will be a road game also. The dates and times of MAC games aren’t announced until spring, but the conference schedule is taking shape. From the MAC…

MAC ANNOUNCES DIVISIONAL ALIGNMENT IN FOOTBALL FOR THE 2012 SEASON
Bowling Green moves to the West Division as UMass joins the East Division beginning this fall.

Cleveland, Ohio – The Mid-American Conference announced today a new divisional alignment in football beginning with the 2012 season as UMass joins the conference to bring the number of football membership to 14 beginning this fall. With the addition of UMass, who will compete in the East Division, Bowling Green State University will move to the MAC West Division.

The divisional alignment was a unanimous vote by the MAC Council of Presidents, as recommended by the Council of Director of Athletics. This alignment will be for football only.

MAC East: Akron; Buffalo; Kent State; UMass; Miami; Ohio and Temple.

MAC West: Ball State; Bowling Green; Central Michigan; Eastern Michigan; Northern Illinois; Toledo and Western Michigan.

“Ever since our announcement of the addition of UMass in football last spring, divisional alignment has been a topic of conversation among our Presidents and Directors of Athletics,” said Dr. Jon Steinbrecher, MAC Commissioner. “We considered a number of different paradigms and ultimately we focused on the core principles of geography, travel and rivalries. We now have a true rotational cycle for football and a scheduling model that will extend for future years.”

This will be the first time since 2006 that the MAC will have balanced divisional schedules. Each member will continue to play an eight-game conference schedule, however each member will now play six divisional games and two non-divisional cross-over games. There will no longer be protected cross-over games.

UMass will begin conference play for the 2012 football season and will be eligible for the conference football championship game and a bowl game beginning in the 2013 football season.

The conference office will announce the 2012 regular season football schedule by the first week of March.

In addition, the MAC announced football opponents for the 2012 season. Ball State will host Eastern Michigan, Western Michigan and Northern Illinois in MAC West games plus Ohio in a MAC crossover contest. The Cardinals will play at Bowling Green, Toledo, Central Michigan in MAC West divisional games plus play at Miami University in a crossover contest.

Surprising? About the divisions, no. And in truth, given the conspiracy theorists amid the BSU fanbase the fact that our crossover games just happen to be against the 2011 MAC Runner Up and the 2010 MAC Champion shouldn’t surprise anyone either. The addition of BG (also on the road) is far tougher than the likes of Akron or Buffalo, but at the very least, it is a winnable game. As up and down as the MAC is, the good teams aren’t good for long and the bad teams are always better than you expect eventually. And considering the lack of attendance at most every MAC school, it’s not like homefield advantage is even something to worry about. Of course, all that’s a moot point since the keg of asswhoop about to be tapped in Muncie cannot be stopped by the MAC or its other members. Isn’t that right, Bill?

Oooooooooo. Politics reference!!! Let the implosion begin.

2011 Ball State Season Rewind: Cards Go to the Movies Part 1.

Rather than just do a standard year in review I looked at the 12 games this season and matched them to movies that came out in 2011. Hope you find it entertaining.

Captain America: Ball State 27 Indiana 20

Who knew Hollywood got their ideas from Ball State football in 2011?

I must confess I was unhappy the game was moved to Indy but this night could not have gone any better for Ball State. Beating IU had a “patriotic” feel to it as the “cupcakes from Bloomington,” as Coach Pete Lembo labeled the Hoosiers, were sent packing.

It was amazing seeing the Ball State offensive line that had been pushed around by the likes of New Hampshire and Liberty under Stan Parrish open up a can on a Big Ten Conference team. Granted, Indiana is the high school dropout turned drug addict member of the Big Ten but that does not take anything away from this win.

Transformers Dark of the Moon: South Florida 35 Ball State 7

Expectations were out of control as some people I knew actually thought Ball State would win this game. Reality hit us all as we were reminded that South Florida is bigger, faster, and playing their home opener after defeating Notre Dame.

It was kind of like my expectations for the recent Transformers movie. I was pumped to see the battle scenes but then remembered that Shia LaBeouf was the star, Megan Fox had been replaced with someone with even less talent and Michael Bay was still the director. The high expectations came crashing down.

Lincoln Lawyer: Ball State 28 Buffalo 25

Ball State came out swinging in this game and built a lead going into half. Then things started slipping away as Buffalo took 25-21 edge in the fourth quarter. Ball State faced a fourth and 13 but Keith Wenning channeled Tim Tebow and pulled it out. The Cardinals then converted on a fourth and seven and scored the touchdown to win. It was the moment where we all knew Keith Wenning was growing into something special.

Wenning’s performance on the drive was similar to Matthew McConaughey’s role in “Lincoln Lawyer.” McConaughey made a late comeback in the courtroom while Wenning made a late comeback on the field. That fourth quarter drive was probably the most thrilling series I saw Ball State make. After so many failures, many in the stands expected Ball State to fold. The offense would not let that happen.

X-Men First Class: Ball State 48 Army 28

This was a complete team win as Ball State dominated every aspect of the game. Seeing Ball State blow out a FBS school that beat Northwestern took me by surprised. I took pictures of the scoreboard just to make sure what I was seeing was real.

Everything came together just as each player brought something to the table like each of the mutants having their own distinct power in X-Men. Wenning had his best game. Barrington Scott and Jahawn Edwards were great running the ball. Willie Sneed had his coming out party at Wide Receiver. The defense shut down Army’s triple option and Sean Baker had another interception. Army did not earn a single yard passing. This was the best performance Ball State has had since Nate Davis was chucking the ball to Dante Love.

scoreboard

We support our troops in Muncie. Just not on the football field.

Harry Potter: Oklahoma 62 Ball State 6

Ball State needed some magic to beat then No. 2 Oklahoma but Harry Potter was nowhere to be seen. I wish Ball State did not schedule this game. Fans pay more attention to you when you play a top team in the country but at what cost? Students kept saying “Didn’t we lose 62-6” for weeks afterword as the Oklahoma game became the only score a majority of the student body could recall. The Army win and momentum from it was virtually erased.

The following Monday safety Joshua Howard gave a doctor’s excuse to my professor for being late to our class and told her he was being tested for a concussion. Losing was bad enough but the injuries on defense were worse. I fail to see how the $900,000 Ball State was paid to take the beating made up for it. The game did not even provide much media exposure either.

If you are still convinced this game should have been scheduled picture what might have happened if Ball State played a Sun Belt conference school like Florida Atlantic and got the win. With seven wins Ball State probably would have played a bowl game. Hope that money buys something nice. If you thought this was bad enough…

Paranormal Activity 3: Temple 42 Ball State 0

A three hour horror movie on a football field. I will try to focus on the positives … uh, Ball State only played Temple once.

What is really damaging is this game discouraged many students from going to another game this season. Finding a buddy to go to a Ball State game with became like trying to find a Republican in California. The defense was depleted with injuries so I guess that is a good excuse. I guess?

The school has to do their homework in the future when it comes to scheduling a homecoming opponent. Ball State students are 95 percent casual fans who only pay attention to the home opener and homecoming. If the Cardinals lose either of those games badly students are not coming back next time. The casual Ball State student does not know the difference between Temple and Eastern Michigan. They just know the Cardinals lost 42-0 to a MAC school at home and therefore Ball State must be terrible. All MAC schools are the same to them. Get a cupcake next year Tom Collins. One with vanilla icing and sprinkles please.

Part 2 of the year in review will come out next week. With the Temple game out of the way I guarantee it will be more upbeat.

Cards Close ’11 on High Note in Classroom

Way to go in the classroom, Cards

As the final week of 2011 winds itself down, I would think that most Cardinals fans are geeked beyond belief at the way the season went. While the Cardinals didn’t go bowling, the on-field successes of this year’s edition of the BSU football squad was not only unexpected by many, it could also prove to be a turning point for the football program should the successes continue. This particular season could lay not only the groundwork for the Lembo era and subsequent career in Muncie and beyond but perhaps be the turning point for Tom Collins era in Muncie as well. I would say no other MAC athletic director has suffered more direct and scathing criticism from the fanbase than Collins over his tenure, so to see him land the right hire and reduce the vocal majority’s yelling to no more than a murmur has been refreshing.

In addition to the on-field successes, the Cards put up a fair share of success in the classroom as well. From Coach Lembo’s most recent newsletter, the academic prowess for the Cards was exemplary in this fall 2011 semester, with four Cards achieving 4.0 GPAs. Having never gotten a 4.0 myself in college (I can’t speak for Edge or RV) I am keenly aware of how difficult that is. To be able to hit that mark while going through the schedule and work for FBS football is amazing. 34 Cards ended up with a 3.0 or better, and while not the gold star that a 4.0 is, hitting that mark with the rigors of football is impressive.

It isn’t all sunshine and roses for the Cardinals though, as Coach Lembo references there are more than a few that need to pick it up academically to continue to be able to play. As he puts it there are a “handful of players did not reach their potential and will have to put forth a much greater effort this spring in the classroom in order to be in good standing.” Whether that “handful” is a couple or a couple dozen isn’t known, but I’d say it’s much more likely to be on the low end of that scale.

Perhaps most ominous in his most recent newsletter was the strangely cryptic, “Only one freshman is in jeopardy of not returning for the spring due to his academic results from the fall semester.” Hopefully that won’t be an issue and things will get themselves corrected via finals and final grades. It’s troubling that that seems more about being able to remain in school as opposed to being able to play football, and that’s a far more serious issue as well as a significantly steeper hill to climb. Worst case scenario and this doesn’t work itself out by spring session and I doubt there will be any official release or news about it. Eventually we’ll just notice that Player X (or Player F as the case may be) isn’t on the roster anymore and that will be a shame. Academic issues and retention or some of the most pressing issues facing higher education today, doubly so in the athletic realm. To lose a member of the squad for academic issues in the face of the various systems of support in place is just sad.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 444 other followers